PCP Car Finance

What Rising Complaints Tell Us About Car Finance Mis-Selling

Complaints about car finance are soaring as regulators scrutinise historic commission models that quietly inflated interest rates.

Car finance mis-selling complaints have surged as regulators scrutinise historic commission practices that inflated interest costs. If a lender or broker failed to disclose or fairly apply commission, you could receive a refund of interest and charges plus statutory interest. National Claims can assess your agreement and guide you through a no-jargon route to compensation.

Car finance complaints aren’t just “in the news”. They’re now the most complained-about credit product at the Financial Ombudsman Service, driven by historic commission models that increased borrowing costs without customers realising. The Financial Conduct Authority has extended a temporary handling pause while it finalises a consumer redress scheme, and major lenders have already set aside hundreds of millions of pounds.

Why complaints are rising now

For years, many brokers and dealers used “discretionary commission” models. In simple terms, the higher the interest rate you paid, the more commission the broker earned. The FCA banned these arrangements in 2021, and in 2024 launched a review of historic cases. As the investigation progressed in 2025, the FCA consulted on a formal compensation scheme and paused complaint response deadlines for most commission complaints until 31 May 2026. That pause remains central to today’s spike in awareness and enquiries.

Meanwhile, banks have increased provisions for potential redress, signalling the scale of likely payouts once rules are finalised. For example, Santander UK recently raised its motor finance redress provision to £461m. Consumers are taking note, and complaint numbers reflect this shift.

What counts as car finance mis-selling?

You may have a claim if one or more of the following happened:

  • The broker or dealer failed to disclose that commission was being paid.
  • The interest rate was increased to fund commission without clear explanation.
  • The finance was unaffordable under responsible lending rules.
  • You were not given fair, balanced information about key alternatives, costs, or risks.
  • You were pressured into quick decisions without time to compare options.

The FCA’s guidance and ongoing consultation focus on historic commission conduct; affordability and information-fail cases can also be valid.

Who is likely to be eligible?

You may be eligible if you took out hire purchase (HP) or personal contract purchase (PCP) between 6 April 2007 and 31 January 2021 (when discretionary commission was banned). Many complaints since 2024 relate to this period. Leasing (pure “rental” with no purchase option) sits outside the proposed scheme and has separate handling rules, which the FCA has already adjusted.

What the data says

The Financial Ombudsman Service reports that hire purchase (motor) became its most complained-about product in 2024/25, with complaints jumping from 21,441 to 76,160 year-on-year. Later in 2025/26, FOS recorded a temporary drop in new motor-finance-commission complaints because of the FCA’s handling pause, while it resolved thousands of existing cases. Both trends reflect a market in transition ahead of the final redress model.

What compensation could include

When car finance is mis-sold, typical redress aims to put you back in the position you’d be in without the misconduct. In practice, that often means:

  • Refund of excess interest/charges caused by undisclosed or unfair commission.
  • Statutory simple interest (commonly 8% per year) on the refunded amounts.
  • Removal of unfair default fees and correction of any negative credit markers.

The statutory interest concept is well-established in the UK and is commonly referenced when calculating simple interest on money owed.

Quick estimate table (guide only)

Redress componentWhat it coversTypical approach
Refund of interest/chargesThe extra you paid due to commission-inflated APRRecalculate as if a fair rate applied
8% simple interestTime value of money on each overpayment8% per year on each overpayment until refund
Fees and add-onsUnfair or mis-sold extrasRefund plus interest if applicable
Credit file clean-upWrongful defaults or markersCorrection and lender notification

Note: The FCA is consulting on the final redress framework. Exact calculations in your case will follow those rules once confirmed.

How National Claims helps

At National Claims, we streamline your route to compensation:

  1. Free check of your agreement(s): We identify commission risk factors fast.
  2. Evidence building: We request key documents and reconstruct payments where needed.
  3. Complaint preparation: We frame a strong, regulator-aligned case.
  4. Ongoing updates: You’ll know what’s happening at each stage.
  5. Maximum redress focus: We challenge low offers and ensure credit-file issues are fixed.

Time limits and your next steps

Even with the current complaint-handling pause, time limits still matter. If your lender rejects a complaint or delays beyond the rules once the pause lifts, you may have six months to escalate to the Financial Ombudsman Service. We preserve your position so deadlines don’t catch you out.

Do this next:

  • Gather your finance agreement, settlement letter, and any emails from the dealer or broker.
  • List every vehicle finance you’ve had since 2007. Many people had multiple agreements.
  • Contact National Claims to run a free eligibility check and protect your claim window.

What about leasing and paused complaints?

Leasing complaints (pure rentals) sit outside the proposed redress scheme, so firms must handle those under the normal rules now. For other commission-related complaints, the FCA has extended the pause so firms do not need to give final responses before it decides the scheme’s scope. This is why complaint volumes in official statistics show unusual patterns during 2025/26.

Will the payouts be “like PPI”?

No one can call the final totals yet. However, banks have begun to provision sizeable sums, and Reuters recently reported a substantial increase at Santander UK for potential motor finance redress. The numbers will depend on your agreement history, the commission model used, and the FCA’s final rules.

Important note on injuries and Linked Claims

Most car finance mis-selling claims are financial. But if your case also involves a road traffic accident or work-related injury, we can run those claims in parallel. Injury compensation in England and Wales is assessed with reference to the latest Judicial College Guidelines ranges for pain, suffering and loss of amenity. If that applies to you, tell us when you enquire.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is there a deadline to claim?
Yes, but it depends on your facts. The FCA’s proposed scheme will set clear processes and cut-offs. We’ll make sure your complaint is lodged correctly and on time.

2. Do I need to wait for the FCA scheme to finish?
Not to talk to us. We can prepare your case now and move as soon as rules are final. For many, early preparation shortens the journey to payment.

3. Will I have to go to the Ombudsman or to court?
Possibly not. Many complaints resolve directly once rules are in place. If needed, the Financial Ombudsman Service can decide your case without a court hearing.

4. How much might I get back?
Every case differs. Typical outcomes include a refund of commission-inflated interest, plus 8% simple interest and fee refunds where appropriate. We’ll estimate this once we review your documents.

5. Will this affect my credit file?
If the mis-selling led to unfair markers or defaults, part of the remedy is to correct your credit record. We press lenders to fix this as part of settlement.

Ready to check your agreements?

Don’t wait while your claim window closes. Speak with National Claims today. We’ll connect you with experienced solicitors who understand your case and fight for the maximum compensation you deserve.

National Claims Logo

About National Claims
This article was written by the National Claims content team. Our specialists have years of experience helping people across the UK with personal injury, road traffic accident, and housing disrepair claims. We work alongside regulated solicitors to ensure our information is accurate, up-to-date, and genuinely useful for anyone seeking to understand their rights after an accident.

Trustpilot

We’re proud of our excellent customer reviews

We thrive on delivering exceptional service and ensuring our clients’ satisfaction. Don’t just take our word for it. Check out some of our independent reviews to see what our clients have to say.

Excellent

Trustpilot

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
LinkedIn

Find out if you have a claim

Get free, no obligation help from a claim specialist.

Related News

Medical Negligence

How to Claim for Post-Surgery Negligence in NHS or Private Hospitals?

Post-surgery negligence can lead to serious complications, from infections and delayed healing to long-term disability. Whether treated by the NHS or a private hospital, you have the right to safe and competent care. If medical staff failed to provide adequate aftercare or made avoidable errors, you may be entitled to compensation.

Hassle-free claims process

Our expert panel of solicitors can typically confirm almost immediately whether your claims application is likely to be successful and also give you an indication of how much you could potentially claim for.