PCP Finance

What’s the Difference Between PPI and Car Finance Claims?

PPI and car finance claims both involve financial mis-selling, but they apply to different products and legal frameworks.

PPI claims relate to insurance sold alongside credit and are largely time-barred after August 2019. Car finance claims focus on unfair interest where dealers/lenders used discretionary commission arrangements (DCAs) without proper disclosure. The FCA has proposed an industry-wide redress scheme for motor finance that could see average payouts of around £700 per agreement.

Why these claims exist

  • PPI (Payment Protection Insurance): Banks and lenders attached insurance to loans/credit cards. Many policies were unsuitable or never explained, leading to the UK’s largest redress exercise (over £38bn paid by 2019). Deadline to complain: 29 August 2019.
  • Car finance (motor finance) mis-selling: From 2007 to 2024, many agreements used DCAs, letting brokers/dealers increase interest to boost their commission. The FCA has proposed an industry-wide compensation scheme; early estimates suggest ~£700 average per eligible agreement and potentially billions in total redress.

PPI vs Car Finance Claims at a Glance

FeaturePPI ClaimsCar Finance Claims
Product in questionInsurance bolted onto creditHire purchase, PCP or conditional sale loan
Core problemUnsuitable cover and/or poor disclosureUndisclosed discretionary commissions inflating interest
Typical period affected1990s–2010sApril 2007–Nov 2024 (DCAs banned in 2021)
Current statusMostly closed after 29 Aug 2019 deadlineActive: FCA consulting on mass redress; lenders expected to contact customers
What redress coversPremiums + interestOverpaid interest + compensatory interest
Average/scale>£38bn paid to consumers by 2019~£700 per agreement (indicative average)
Who overseesFCA (historic campaign)FCA scheme and complaint rules

How eligibility differs

PPI eligibility (brief, for context)

  • You were sold PPI you didn’t need, couldn’t use, or wasn’t explained.
  • Most consumers can no longer start new PPI complaints because the 2019 deadline has passed.

Car finance eligibility (the current focus)

You may have a valid claim if you had HP, PCP, or conditional sale finance and any of the following apply:

  1. The dealer/lender failed to disclose commission or how it affected your interest rate.
  2. You were steered into a higher APR than necessary because of DCA incentives.
  3. Fees/charges were unclear or misleading.

The FCA has outlined how firms should handle these complaints and is working towards a consumer redress scheme to deliver a consistent, streamlined outcome for agreements between 2007 and 2024.

Evidence you’ll need

  • Your finance agreement (or the car registration/approximate dates).
  • Any dealer/lender communications (quotes, order forms, pre-contract info).
  • Bank statements showing payments.
  • Notes on what the salesperson told you about interest/commissions.

Tip: Even if you don’t have paperwork, National Claims can help trace your agreement. Research shows many households rely on car finance—underscoring how widespread potential harm can be.

What compensation could you receive?

Car finance redress usually returns the extra interest you paid because of unfair commission, plus compensatory interest. While the exact figure depends on your agreement, current reporting suggests ~£700 per eligible agreement on average within an FCA-led scheme.

Simple illustration (indicative only)

ScenarioPotential Redress Components
PCP with undisclosed DCARefund of excess interest + compensatory interest (simple interest)
HP with unfair rate upliftRefund of overpaid interest + compensatory interest
Multiple agreementsEach agreement assessed separately under scheme rules

Note: If a personal injury element ever arises from related circumstances (e.g., stress or consequential harm), solicitors typically reference the Judicial College Guidelines (JCG) to value those injury heads of loss. Financial mis-selling itself is about economic loss, but any injury claim would be assessed using JCG ranges. (JCG is the standard reference used by courts and practitioners in England & Wales.)

Legal framework

  • Consumer Credit Act 1974 governs many car finance agreements and sets out consumer rights around credit and redress routes (including court and ombudsman).
  • The FCA regulates consumer credit firms and has been consulting on a motor finance redress scheme to resolve DCA-related complaints fairly and efficiently.
  • Government guidance also explains when a business must be authorised to offer credit or hire purchase.

Timelines: PPI vs Car Finance

  • PPI – Most new complaints closed after 29 August 2019. If you didn’t complain by then, options are very limited.
  • Car finance – The FCA’s proposed scheme targets agreements from 2007–2024 and aims to contact affected customers through lenders and brokers. If you had finance in this period, act now so your claim is positioned properly.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is car finance the “new PPI”?
Not exactly. While the potential payouts are large, the regulator expects the scope to be smaller than PPI, with a structured process via an FCA scheme rather than years of open-ended complaints.

2. Do I need my original paperwork?
No. It helps, but we can often identify your agreement from basic details and lender records.

3. What if I settled early or refinanced?
You may still have paid inflated interest during the period the DCA applied. That’s assessable.

4. Can I claim if I bought the car in cash?
No—these claims relate to credit agreements (HP, PCP, conditional sale).

5. Will this affect my current car?
Redress is about past payments. It shouldn’t change ownership of the vehicle.

How National Claims maximises your outcome

Research demonstrates that specialist, evidence-led casebuilding increases the chance of accurate redress. We:

  • Audit your agreement for undisclosed commissions and unfair rate uplifts.
  • Calculate overpaid interest and interest on that sum, in line with expected FCA methodology.
  • Liaise with finance firms under evolving FCA rules to protect your position.

What to do now

  1. Check your dates: Did you have HP/PCP/conditional sale between 2007 and 2024?
  2. Start a free check with National Claims—we’ll confirm eligibility quickly.
  3. Upload what you can (agreement, quotes, emails).
  4. We’ll take it from there and guide you through the process.

Final call to action

Think you overpaid on car finance between 2007 and 2024? Start your claim with National Claims today. we’ll review your agreement, quantify your losses and pursue the maximum redress available under the evolving FCA framework.

Don’t wait while your claim window closes. Speak with National Claims today. We’ll connect you with experienced solicitors who understand your case and fight for the maximum compensation you deserve.

National Claims Logo

About National Claims
This article was written by the National Claims content team. Our specialists have years of experience helping people across the UK with personal injury, road traffic accident, and housing disrepair claims. We work alongside regulated solicitors to ensure our information is accurate, up-to-date, and genuinely useful for anyone seeking to understand their rights after an accident.

Trustpilot

We’re proud of our excellent customer reviews

We thrive on delivering exceptional service and ensuring our clients’ satisfaction. Don’t just take our word for it. Check out some of our independent reviews to see what our clients have to say.

Excellent

Trustpilot

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
LinkedIn

Find out if you have a claim

Get free, no obligation help from a claim specialist.

Related News

Medical Negligence

How to Claim for Post-Surgery Negligence in NHS or Private Hospitals?

Post-surgery negligence can lead to serious complications, from infections and delayed healing to long-term disability. Whether treated by the NHS or a private hospital, you have the right to safe and competent care. If medical staff failed to provide adequate aftercare or made avoidable errors, you may be entitled to compensation.

Hassle-free claims process

Our expert panel of solicitors can typically confirm almost immediately whether your claims application is likely to be successful and also give you an indication of how much you could potentially claim for.